1999年7月，《科技之光》制作了一部電視專題片《李洪志“經(jīng)文”點評》。該片選取李洪志多年來在各地“講法”的大量內(nèi)容進行了剖析。相信今天重看此片，仍會留給我們強烈的震撼和深長的思索。
本片具有較強的“娛樂性”，李洪志如一個“滿嘴跑火車”的“單口相聲演員”，常常能做到“語不驚人死不休”。例如他關(guān)于“地球毀滅81次”的論述；例如大言不慚地自夸：“這個宇宙我最大，連我的爹媽也是我做的?！?/font>
本片共分五部分，將從周一至周五連續(xù)播出，并附有中英文對照解說詞。歡迎收看和下載。
點擊播放視頻
——編者
李洪志“經(jīng)文”點評（之二）
關(guān)于天命、神諭、輪回、報應(yīng)的妖言邪說
（女播音員） 李洪志歪理邪說的另一個基本內(nèi)容，便是他反動的天命觀和輪回報應(yīng)說。
（男播音員）他認為小到一個人的壽夭窮通，大到一個國家的興衰存亡，一切全由天定。請看他是如何信口胡謅的。
（錄像，李洪志）神在這看著了，這個空間有管人本身倫理的 ，有管社會穩(wěn)定的，有管安排各種體系的，有操縱地球穩(wěn)定的，有管空氣的，和各種空氣成份的，還有他都不同的神對地球不同的事。什么樣的神都有在這里面?！?/p>
（女播音員）聽上去，李洪志真對神的事一清二楚，如數(shù)家珍。但稍稍一想就能看出，完全是按人類社會的行政管理模式照套照搬的。那么，人又該如何度過一生呢？
（錄像，李洪志）那么我們個人奮斗啊，想要通過社會發(fā)展哪，我們自己想要達到什么目的呀，這都不用做了嘛，這都在那里存在嘛。對！我告訴你說呢，一切都在那里存在著。你只不過是按照導(dǎo)好的這出戲在演，電影已經(jīng)有了膠片了，只不過在放?！?/p>
（男播音員）如果信了李洪志的話，人來到世上只能嚴格按照神編寫好的演出臺本與時間表出場和行動，人是沒有能力作任何選擇和絲毫改變的。再請聽李洪志怎樣教導(dǎo)他的弟子。
（錄像，李洪志）因為那個高級生命哪，它在安排人的生命的時候，它可不是按照你的能力大小本事，在常人中的本事大小來安排，這啥也不是，它看的這啥也不是。它是按照人的業(yè)力安排的。這個人哪，德簡直太大了，你看，你拼死拼活你也掙不過他。他啥也不是，他德太大了，那一百元大票成麻袋往家背，說不上，你呀，干啥啥行。你一天掙不到一塊錢。
（女播音員）瞧，這么說來，什么勤儉發(fā)家，勞動致富統(tǒng)統(tǒng)都毫無必要。人生的一切奮斗和進取都將注定是枉費心機，一切創(chuàng)造和追求都應(yīng)該完全放棄，生命的意義只剩下盤腿修煉了。
（男播音員）李洪志的天命論，說的還不僅是普通百姓的吉兇禍福。
（錄像，李洪志）......福份大的，能力大的，他一定要安排他......福份小的，能力小的，他絕對當不了大官，不管那個巴黎公社怎么樣，推翻了君主制，可是我告訴大家，在這個巴黎歷代所競選的這個總統(tǒng)啊，總理呀，也都是過去的皇帝。
（男播音員）真太讓人啼笑皆非了。命好的生生世世做大官，命壞的永永遠遠是草民。且不說法國末代君主路易十六是１７９２年被法國資產(chǎn)階級革命推翻的，而巴黎公社卻是七十九年后無產(chǎn)階級推翻資產(chǎn)階級的第一次嘗試，單說法國的歷任總統(tǒng)都是過去皇帝轉(zhuǎn)世的，不知道戴高樂、篷皮杜諸公，如果有幸聆聽中國奇人李洪志的這番高論，會作出何等感想。
（女播音員）既然命運不能改變，那么能不能預(yù)先知道呢，李洪志給出的答案是肯定的。
（錄像，李洪志）說這個宿命通的人哪，可以看到啊，一個人的一生。他的前半生，后半生，甚至于可以突破這個范圍看到更遙遠。有的人哪，功能很強很大，可以看到一個社會的發(fā)展演變。有的呢，可以看到更大空間范圍之內(nèi)的，它的變化、演變、演化過程。
（男播音員）原來法輪功有這種本事，調(diào)閱和查看為每個人編好的戲劇臺本或者放映膠片。比起其它算命先生，李洪志顯然技高一籌了。他對宿命論還有全方位的論述。
（錄像，李洪志）你的生命已經(jīng)產(chǎn)生很長時間了，也不知道在世間有多少父母，多少兒女呢，哪個是你真的，是吧。只有原始生你的父母，才是真的。
（女播音員）我想任何一個心智健全的人聽了他的話都會驚得目瞪口呆。照他的說法，一個人上輩子可能是他兒子的孫子，下輩子可能是一棵植物。
（男播音員）這下我們明白了，怪不得好多法輪功弟子修煉之后，放棄了今生今世的親情、友情、愛情這些被稱為執(zhí)著心的常人之情，變得拋家不顧，丟掉了人妻人母，人父人子應(yīng)盡的責(zé)任，從此和我們幽明永隔。
（女播音員）法輪功就這樣破壞了人間正常的倫理關(guān)系和健康的社會秩序。李洪志還不惜把自己爹娘擺進去，作了更精彩的論述。
（錄像，李洪志）這個宇宙的年齡我最大，連我生生世世的父母都是我造的。
（男播音員）我們簡直不能相信自己的耳朵。為了裝神弄鬼，欺世盜名，竟然連自己的生身父母都可以當著眾人隨意作賤。這樣的人，世上還真不多見。
（女播音員）那么看看李洪志又是如何確定人類社會的生活準則呢？
（錄像，李洪志）現(xiàn)在人好與壞，你知道它有什么因緣關(guān)系互相之間？他罵他一句就也許他已經(jīng)欠了一句，他打一拳他也許已經(jīng)欠他一拳。這些事情你不要管，他自有常人中人去管，常人中的法管常人中的事，你是個超常的人，你要做這種事情。你看不到這種因緣關(guān)系，可能你覺得做了一件好事，其實是壞事。
（女播音員）李洪志是在教導(dǎo)他的弟子說，天意不可違，誰都不能干擾神的部署，打亂天意的安排而自作主張。按他的邏輯，殺人犯和被殺者是在結(jié)清前世的冤孽，一報一還。英雄舍己救人，壯烈捐軀，也絲毫不值得敬仰，因為英雄前世一定欠過被救者一命。
（男播音員）李洪志妄圖從根本上否定人間的一切助人為樂和見義勇為。并勸人放縱和容忍邪惡。
（女播音員）法輪功不僅要規(guī)定人們社會生活的行為準則，還妄圖解釋人類歷史上戰(zhàn)爭發(fā)生的原因。
（錄像，李洪志）為什么古代有戰(zhàn)爭啊，我告訴你那是天定的。因為宇宙中的神，給人這個空間定下了這么兩條根本就不可能改變，更不容許改變的，就是叫做兵爭下天，王者治國。
（男播音員）李洪志當然不會懂得戰(zhàn)爭是階級、民族、國家之間政治的繼續(xù)。按他的理論，戰(zhàn)爭完全是天的意志，神的游戲。自然也談不上正義與非正義之分了。
（女播音員）他在《轉(zhuǎn)法輪》中曾說過，岳飛再強也挽救不了宋朝，因為違背了天意。李洪志不僅僅只談?wù)撨b遠的歷史，請聽一段錄音。
（錄音，李洪志）慘絕人寰的南京大屠殺啊，300萬，300多萬人死難同胞的心性是怎么回事，你問誰呢，你知道他是怎么回事嗎？我告訴你啊，有些人哪，你怎么講，他也不太相信，你300萬人算什么呀，那兩顆原子彈死了多少人，歷史上在戰(zhàn)爭中死了多少人，第二次世界大戰(zhàn)死了多少人，希特勒屠殺了多少人，這些事情我可以告訴你，我可以概括地告訴你，啊，我可以概括地告訴你，這都是天象變化帶來的，這是整個宇宙的天象變化帶來的，任何事情都有因緣關(guān)系。
（男播音員）我們再也不能壓抑心中的怒火。哪一個有血性的中國人提起南京大屠殺不是仇恨滿腔，肅然動容！在李洪志看來，三十萬南京同胞慘遭荼毒，都是因為心性不好，命該如此！日本軍國主義的瘋狂暴行竟要由神來承擔了！我們海內(nèi)外每一個炎黃子孫都不會饒過李洪志這個民族罪人！
（女播音員）講完了關(guān)于戰(zhàn)爭的一派胡言，李洪志又打算從整體上講解人類文明發(fā)展的進程了。
（錄像，李洪志）神安排了人類社會的發(fā)展，你比如說在中國古代，派下一個神來，讓他來造紙，派下一個神來做指南針，是吧，他是完成了這件事情給大家用了。
（錄像，李洪志）是神給人安排的，蔡倫造紙哪，這個指南針啊，包括這個中國的大醫(yī)學(xué)家，許許多多陶瓷的發(fā)明哪，包括西方玻璃的發(fā)明，都是天、神安排的這個人下來做這件事情。
（女播音員）實在叫人拍案驚奇。中華民族的祖先對人類最驕傲的貢獻，世界公認的中國四大發(fā)明，也都被說成是神的功勞，我想，每一個稍有歷史知識和民族自尊心的中國人都絕不會同意。
（男播音員）中國和世界歷史發(fā)展的足跡本來一清二楚，明明是千百萬人民群眾的偉大實踐和科學(xué)的力量創(chuàng)造了今天的人類文明，李洪志卻說是神在按計劃一步一步給人類賜福和降災(zāi)。那么，李洪志的興趣僅限于談一談古人嗎？再請聽李洪志的一段講話。
（錄像，李洪志）還有的人剛才提出來說你們師傅那么有本事，為什么不把國家的經(jīng)濟搞好。大家都樂了，是呀，誰都知道，人類社會的發(fā)展，是按照規(guī)律在發(fā)展。到了哪一步應(yīng)該怎么樣，那是神決定的。想怎么干怎么干，于是把你經(jīng)濟搞好，天下早大亂了。你人哪想干什么神就得給你干什么嗎？你人要想干什么，那么天就得給你做什么嗎？神都聽你指揮嗎？你覺得國家經(jīng)濟搞好了重要，你知道神把其它的事情看得更重要。你知道人沒有福份，是因為他的道德不行，人心太壞，人變得那么壞了，還想要這要那，誰給你呀！人要想有福份，那就得減少業(yè)力，有大德，不然的話，還不只是這個經(jīng)濟不好，天災(zāi)人禍什么都有，連年不斷。
（女播音員）李洪志的真實面目至此已經(jīng)完全暴露無遺。他要從根本上完全否定了中國人民為實現(xiàn)四個現(xiàn)代化所作的一切努力。在他看來，我們?yōu)檎衽d中華作出的全部奮斗統(tǒng)統(tǒng)是一場空忙。我們政府制定的一個又一個五年計劃，都不可能絲毫改變神的計劃。
（男播音員）他還兇相畢露地把各種自然災(zāi)害都說成是天對我們國家的警告和懲罰。透過李洪志這些惡毒之極的詛咒，我們活生生地看到了他反社會，反政府，反人民的猙獰嘴臉。
（女播音員）說到這里，人們大概都會忍不住有一個問題想向李大師討教。既然人間萬事都由命中注定，李大師又能洞察天機，透達古今，一切都納入運籌掌握之中，為何獨獨沒有預(yù)見到法輪大法1999年的徹底復(fù)滅和可恥下場！
Critical Comments On Li Hongzhi's "Scripture" (Part 2)
The Devious Words and Sayings About Fate, Prophecies, Reincarnation, Retributions
Female commentator: Another basic component of Li Hongzhi’s devious theories and saying is his reactionary view of fate and retribution in reincarnation.
Male commentator: He posits that from the life-span, wealth-status of a person, to the rises and falls of a state, everything is determined by fate. Let us say how his nonsense is spelled out.
Video of Li Hongzhi: The gods are watching, this space have gods controlling human ethics, controlling social stabilities, controlling and arranging all types of systems, some controlling the stability of the earth, some controlling the air, and the airs, and every different deity controls different aspects of the earth. This has every type of gods.
Female commentator: Listening to this, Li Hongzhi seems to be very clear about the affairs of the gods, counting them as his household. But if we give it a bit thinking, this scheme is a copy from the human administrative system. Then, how should human beings spend their lifes?
Video of Li Hongzhi: So, all our individual striving, wishing to develop socially, reaching our goals, none of these has to be done, all exist over there. Right, I am telling you, all exist over there. You are only playing a role according to the director, the movie has been made, it is only the playing of it.
Male commentator: If we believe in Li Hongzhi’s words, human is only performing the script according to gods’ composition in time and acts, humans have no capability to choose and deviate even the slightest. Let us listen to how Li Hongzhi instructs his disciples.
Video of Li Hongzhi: Because of the higher life forms, in his arranging of human lives, does not do so according to your abilities, not according to your abilities in the normal people, nothing like that at all, it sees your abilities as nothing. He arranges it according to the person’s karma. Oh, this person, the virtue is so great; look, you try to your bitter end still cannot make as much as he does. He is nothing, but his virtues are so great, he is carrying bundles of 100 yuan notes home. You, have nothing to compare, you can hardly make 1 yuan a day.
Female commentator: Look, according to this saying, it is unnecessary to work diligently to accumulate wealth through work. All strivings and progresses of lives are destined to be a waste of efforts, all creativities and pursuits should be abandoned, the meaning of life is left to cultivating cross-legged.
Male commentator: The theory of Fate according to Li Hongzhi reaches beyond the fortunes of ordinary citizens.
Video of Li Hongzhi: …Those of great fortunes, great capabilities, He will arrange him…the smaller fortunes ones, smaller capabilities, he can never hold high offices. Regardless of whatever happened to the Paris Commune, overthrowing the monarchy, let me tell you, the presidents, prime ministers of Paris in history, were actually reincarnations of past emperors.
Male commentator: This is really ridiculous. Those with good fortunes hold high offices life after life, those without are forever grass-root citizens. Let alone the fact that the last French Emperor Louis XVI was dethroned by the bourgeois revolution, and that the Paris Commune was the first attempt of the proletariats to overthrow the bourgeois regime seventy-nine years later; should it be true that all presidents in the French history are reincarnations of past emperors, what would de Gaulle and Pompidou think had they had the chance to listen to the musings of this rare man named Li Hongzhi from China?
Female commentator: If fate cannot be changed, then can it be foretold? Li Hongzhi gives a positive answer.
Video of Li Hongzhi: For those with the capabilities to foretell the future, they can see the whole life of a person. His first half of life, his second half of life, and even see beyond this range to much further. Some people having great strong capabilities, can see the development and changes of a society. Some can even see bigger space, its changes, evolution, and transformation.
Male commentator: Given this capability of Falungong, it can reveal all performance scripts and movie film designed for everyone. Comparing to the street-fortune-tellers, Li Hongzhi is obviously highly skilled. He has a full dimension of the theories of fate.
Video of Li Hongzhi: Your life has been produced long times ago, not knowing how many parents, how many children you have; which one is the true parent? Right? Only your primitive originating parents are real.
Female commentator: I would guess anyone with common sense should be shocked upon hearing this. According to his saying, a person can be the grandson of his son’s in his previous life, and a plant in his next life.
Male commentator: this allows us to understand why many Falungong disciples abandon the feelings for family, friendship, love—all those labeled as normal peoples’ attachments, and change into someone neglecting families, neglecting the responsibilities as wife, husband, mother, father, and be separated from us forever.
Female commentator: Falungong thus destroys the normal ethical and healthy social order. Li Hongzhi even places his parents into this scheme to make the point.
Video of Li Hongzhi: In this Universe, my age is the oldest, even all my past parents were created by me.
Male commentator: We could hardly believe our ears. To portray his spiritual magic, to make a name for himself, he even debases his own parents in public. Persons like this are hard to find in this world.
Female commentator: Now, let us examine how Li Hongzhi defines the principles for human social lifes.
Video of Li Hongzhi: The good and bad of the people, you know what are the causes and effects? He scolded him once, that is perhaps he (the one being scolded) owed him one. He hit him once, perhaps he (the victim) owed him one. You should not be concerned with these matters, he will be taken cared of by the normal people, the ordinary law among the common people takes care of this. You are super-normal, if you want to do these things (to stop the fight), you cannot see this causality, you feel you have done a good thing, but you actually do a bad thing.
Female commentator: Li Hongzhi is instructing his followers: the will of the heaven cannot be violated, no one can interfere with the gods’ plan, disturbing the arrangement by heavenly will and insert himself. According to his logic, murderers and their victims are merely settling the scores of karma from their previous lives, retribution in one. Heroes sacrificing their lives for others should not deserve respects, because such an act was repaying the life owed to the beneficiary in the previous life.
Male commentator: Li Hongzhi attempts to deny all charities and courageous acts in the human society, and advices people to tolerate evils.
Female commentator: Falungong not only wants to regulate the principles of people’s social behaviors, it also attempt to distort the causes of wars in human history.
Video of Li Hongzhi: Why there were wars in the ancient time? I tell you, it was determined by the heaven. Because the gods in the Universe have given human in this space two fundamentally unchangeable (rules), much less allow it to change, it is: armed to conquered, the king rules.
MALE COMMENTATOR: Li Hongzhi certainly does not understand that wars are the continuations of politics among the classes, nations, and states. According to his theory, wars are the wills of heaven, a game played by the gods, and have nothing to do with justice.
FEMALE COMMENTATOR: In his Zhuan Falun, he claimed that Yue Fei, no matter however strong he could be, could not save the Song Dynasty, because he acted against the heavenly will. Li Hongzhi does not only comment on histories of remote past, here is a recording.
Audio of Li Hongzhi: The Rape of Nanking, horrific, 300 thousand people. What are the Xinxing (mind-nature) of these 300 thousand people, whom you should ask, do you know what that was? I tell you, some people, how should I say it, whatever you tell them, he will not believe. What did your 300 thousand account to? How many died in the two atomic bombs? How many died in the wars in history? How many perished in World War II? How many did Hitler kill? These things I can tell you, I can summarily tell you, ah, I can tell you in summary, were brought by the changes in the heavenly phenomenon, brought by the heavenly phenomena in the whole Universe. Everything has its cause and effects.
MALE COMMENTATOR: We cannot hold down our anger. Any Chinese of character will be infuriated with anger for the Rape of Nanking! But to Li Hongzhi, the murder of 300 thousand compatriots in Nanking was due to their not-so-good Xinxing, and destined by fate! The murderous acts of Japanese militaristic acts are the burden of gods! All descendents of Chinese all over the world will not let go of Li Hongzhi, this criminal against the nation.
FEMALE COMMENTATOR: Finishing his nonsense about wars, Li Hongzhi attempts to take explain the civilization development of humanity.
Video of Li Hongzhi: The gods have arranged the development of human society. For example, in ancient China, a god was sent down to make paper, another to make the compass. Right, he finished these for everyone to use.
Video of Li Hongzhi: This is arranged by gods, the paper-maker Cai Lun. This compass, including all the great doctors of China, many many pottery and porcelain inventions, including the glass in the west, are all arranged by the heaven, and gods, sending down people to do these.
FEMALE COMMENTATOR: This is a weird story. The proudest contributions to humanity by the ancestors of Chinese, the Four Great Inventions recognized all over the world, are portrayed as the deeds of gods. I guess, any Chinese with a sense of history and national pride would disagree.
MALE COMMENTATOR: The footprints of development of China and the World are very clear: today’s civilization is the results of great experiments and creativity by science performed by millions and millions of people. Li Hongzhi insists that they are the gifts or misfortunes given by gods. Then, is Li Hongzhi’s interest focused on the ancients? Let us listen to a passage by Li Hongzhi.
Video of Li Hongzhi: Just now, someone suggested, your Master has such great capabilities, why not contribute to improving the state’s economy? Every one was laughing. Yes, everyone knows, the development of human society is moving according to rules, what to do next is decided by gods. If you want to do this and that, and you improve the economy, the world will be in chaos. Do the gods allow you to do what you want? You human want to do something, so that the heaven will allow you? The gods follow your directions? You may feel that a good economy is important to the state, but do you know that the gods take other things more seriously. You know that people do not deserve fortunes because their merits and virtues are not good, they have bad heart. When people are so corrupt, you still want this and that? Who will give them to you! Human want fortune must reduce their karma, collect great virtues. Otherwise, it is not only bad economy, it calls for disasters in nature and the human, followed year after year.
FEMALE COMMENTATOR: The true face of Li Hongzhi has been fully exposed by now. He is fundamentally denying all the Chinese people have done for the four modernizations. From his view, all we have done to reinvigorate the nation was in vain, all the five-year plans we have will not fundamentally change any of the gods’ plan.
MALE COMMENTATOR: He also deviously claims that all natural disasters are warning and punishments from heaven on the nation. From the venomous curses of Li Hongzhi’s, we can see his ugly face of anti-society, anti-government, and anti-human.
FEMALE COMMENTATOR: Upon this time, people may want to ask Master Li a question: when everything is predetermined by fate, and since Master Li can see through the secrets of heaven, from past into the future, and everything is under his control, why he does not foretell the shameful fall of Falungong in 1999?
